She nodded and picked up her desk phone. “Let me get Karen Walsh for you. She handles these requests.”
A few minutes later, a woman emerged from one of the back offices. Early forties, blonde hair pulled back in a neat bun, kind eyes behind wire-rimmed glasses.
“Anna Preston?” she asked, extending her hand. “I’m Karen Walsh, patient relations specialist. Come on back to my office.”
We sat down in a small office lined with filing cabinets. She pulled up my grandfather’s file on her computer.
“What can I help you with?” she asked.
I explained the situation as clearly as I could. The advanced directive from 2018 that my family had faxed over. The pressure to change his code status to DNR. My concern that there might be something more recent that conflicted with it.
“I’ve never heard my grandfather talk about limiting care,” I said. “Never heard him mention that advanced directive. And I’m wondering if there might be something more current in his records.”
Karen typed into her computer, pulling up different screens, scrolling through databases.
“Okay,” she said slowly, leaning forward to read something on the screen. “So, I’m seeing the 2018 advanced directive that was faxed to us yesterday. That’s in the system now as of this morning.”
She clicked to another screen.
“But when I search the legal-documents folder, there’s something interesting here. A notation from March 18, 2025.”
My heart started pounding. “What does it say?”
“It says: Patient called regarding health care proxy update. New POA documents signed and executed. Pending scan to medical records department.”
She looked up at me.
“But I don’t see the actual document uploaded to the system.”
“What does that mean?” I asked.
“It means someone, likely your grandfather himself or possibly his attorney, contacted our medical records department about updating his health care proxy. They noted that new power-of-attorney documents were signed, but for some reason the physical documents were never scanned into our electronic system.”
“So there might be a newer directive that supersedes the 2018 one?”
“Possibly,” Karen said. “The notation indicates intent to update, but without the physical documents, I can’t confirm what they say or whether they actually override the older directive.”
She scrolled down further.
“There’s a phone number listed here. Let me see.” She squinted at the screen. “Caldwell and Hayes Legal Group. 503-555-8821.”
“A law firm. Can you contact them?” I asked.
“I can,” Karen said. “And I should. This is exactly the kind of situation where we need to clarify legal authority before making any medical decisions.”
She started typing an email.
“If there are two conflicting directives, one from 2018 and one potentially from 2025, we can’t act on either one until we verify which is valid and enforceable.”
She paused and looked at me.
“I’m going to send an urgent email to this law firm. I’ll copy you and our hospital legal department. We need to sort this out before Dr. Cole or anyone else makes changes to code status.”
“Thank you,” I said.
Karen sent the email at 3:42 p.m.
Subject: Urgent: Patient Directive Conflict — George Preston.
Dear Caldwell and Hayes Legal Group, we have a patient, George Preston, DOB 4/9/47, currently hospitalized at Providence Heart and Vascular Institute with post-surgical complications. Our records indicate a health care proxy update was initiated on March 18, 2025, but we do not have updated documents on file. Family has submitted a 2018 advanced directive. Due to this conflict, we are unable to proceed with requested code-status changes until legal authority is clarified. Please respond urgently regarding current health care proxy status.
Karen Walsh, Patient Relations Specialist, Providence Heart and Vascular Institute.
She copied me, the hospital legal department, and the ethics committee chair.
The auto-response came back within seconds.
Thank you for your message. This office responds to urgent matters within one business day.
Karen printed out a copy of the email thread and handed it to me.
“We should hear back by tomorrow,” she said. “In the meantime, I’m putting a hold on any code-status changes until this is resolved.”
I went back to the ICU.
My grandfather had been sleeping most of the day. The infection was taking a lot out of him, but the antibiotics were starting to work. His temperature had come down to one hundred point two. His lactate was trending down, two point three at the last check.
I sat in the chair beside his bed and watched him breathe. In, out. In, out. The ventilator was gone now. He was breathing on his own, even if it was still a struggle.
I whispered, even though I knew he probably couldn’t hear me. “Who’s James Caldwell, Grandpa? And why didn’t you tell me?”
His hand twitched in his sleep.
The response came the next morning, November 21, at 9:15 a.m.
I was in the hospital cafeteria, forcing myself to eat something, a dry bagel and bad coffee, when my phone dinged with an email notification.
From: Jennifer Hayes, Esquire, jhayes@caldwellhays.com
To: Karen Walsh, kwalsh@providence.org
CC: Anna Preston, hospital legal, ethics committee
Subject: Re: Urgent Patient Directive Conflict — George Preston
Dear Ms. Walsh and Ms. Preston,
Thank you for your inquiry regarding Mr. George Preston’s health care directives. Our firm does indeed represent Mr. Preston in estate-planning and health care proxy matters. We have on file the updated health care power-of-attorney documents which were executed on March 18, 2025. These documents supersede all prior directives, including the 2018 advanced directive referenced in your email.
Additionally, Mr. Preston left specific instructions with our office regarding materials to be delivered in the event of his hospitalization or incapacitation. Attorney James Caldwell will personally deliver notarized copies of all relevant documents to Providence Heart and Vascular Institute tomorrow, November 22, at approximately 2:00 p.m. He will also bring additional materials Mr. Preston specifically requested be given to Ms. Anna Preston under these circumstances.
Time is of the essence in these matters, and Mr. Caldwell will ensure all documentation is properly submitted to your legal department.
Respectfully,
Jennifer Hayes, Esquire
Caldwell and Hayes Legal Group
I read the email three times.
Updated health care power of attorney executed March 18, 2025.
Additional materials Mr. Preston specifically requested.
What additional materials?
I forwarded the email to myself and then headed back up to my grandfather’s room.
He’d been moved out of the ICU that morning. The infection was responding well enough to the antibiotics that they felt comfortable transferring him to the cardiac step-down unit. Same room number, just a different floor. 4218.
When I walked in, he was awake, sitting up at about a forty-five-degree angle. The oxygen cannula was still in his nose, but he was breathing easier. The nurse had helped him eat some applesauce and Jell-O for breakfast. He saw me, and his eyes focused immediately.
“Did someone contact you?” he asked. His voice was still rough but stronger than yesterday.
I sat down in the chair beside his bed. “An attorney. James Caldwell. He’s coming tomorrow.”
My grandfather closed his eyes, let out a long, slow breath, then nodded.
“Good,” he said quietly. “It’s time.”
“Grandpa, what’s going on?”
He opened his eyes and looked at me.
“Tomorrow,” he said. “When James gets here, you’ll understand everything. I promise.”
“Can’t you tell me now?”
“I could,” he said. “But I need you to hear it the right way, from James, with the documentation. So you know I wasn’t confused. So you know this was my choice.”
He reached out and took my hand.
“Do you trust me?” he asked.
“Of course I do.”
“Then trust me one more day,” he said. “Tomorrow, everything will make sense.”
November 22, 2:15 p.m. exactly.
I was sitting in the chair beside my grandfather’s bed. He’d been dozing on and off all morning. The infection was under control now. He’d been afebrile for twenty-four hours. They’d switched his antibiotics from IV to oral. The discharge-planning team was already talking about moving him to a rehabilitation facility in a few days.
There was a knock on the door.
A man entered. About sixty years old, gray hair neatly combed, wire-rimmed glasses, gray suit with a burgundy tie. He was carrying a black leather briefcase with a combination lock on the front. He had the bearing of someone who’d spent a lifetime in courtrooms and law offices. Professional. Precise. But his eyes were kind.
“Anna Preston?” he asked.
I stood up. “Yes.”
“My name is James Caldwell. I’m your grandfather’s attorney.”
He looked past me to the bed. “George, it’s good to see you awake.”
My grandfather’s eyes opened. He smiled weakly. “James. Thank you for coming.”
“Of course,” James said.
He set his briefcase down on the rolling bedside table and turned back to me.
“Karen Walsh from patient relations contacted my office two days ago regarding a conflict in your grandfather’s advance directives. I believe we have quite a bit to discuss.”
He gestured to the briefcase.
“May I?”
My grandfather’s voice was steady. “Show her everything.”
James clicked the combination lock on the briefcase. I noticed the numbers as he spun the dial.
April 9, 1947.
My grandfather’s birthday.
The lock clicked open. James lifted the lid and carefully removed three items. He laid them on the bedside table in careful order.
First, a thick document, official-looking, multiple pages bound together. I could see a notary seal on the front page.
Second, a small USB drive, the kind you’d use to store computer files. It had a piece of white label tape on it with handwriting in blue ink: For Anna. Emergency only.
Third, a sealed envelope, white, business-size. On the front, in my grandfather’s shaky handwriting: For Anna.
James picked up the thick document first.
“This,” he said, his voice formal and precise, “is your grandfather’s health care power of attorney executed on March 18, 2025. It explicitly names you, Anna Marie Preston, as his primary health care agent. It revokes all prior advance directives, including the 2018 directive that your family submitted to the hospital.”
He handed it to me.
I took it with shaking hands. The paper felt substantial. Official.
The title page read: Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care Decisions.
Below that:
I, George Preston, of sound mind and legal capacity, do hereby appoint Anna Marie Preston as my attorney-in-fact for health care decisions.
I flipped through the pages. Eight pages total. Dense legal language, but clear.
In the event that I am unable to make my own medical decisions due to incapacity, unconsciousness, or inability to communicate, I hereby grant my health care agent, Anna Marie Preston, full authority to make all health care decisions on my behalf, including but not limited to consent to or refusal of any medical treatment, determination of code status, including CPR and DNR orders, decisions regarding life-sustaining treatment, selection of health care providers and facilities, access to all medical records and information.
Page six had my grandfather’s signature. Shaky, his hands weren’t as steady as they used to be, but unmistakably his. The signature was dated March 18, 2025.
Below his signature were two witness signatures, Sarah Chen and Michael Torres, names I didn’t recognize. At the bottom of the page was a notary seal. Jennifer Hayes, Notary Public, State of Oregon, commission number 84521.
Everything looked official. Legal. Binding.
I looked up at my grandfather.
“March 18,” I said. “You did this eight months ago.”
“I had to,” he said. “I knew what might be coming.”
I looked back at the other two items on the table. The USB drive. The envelope.
“What are these?” I asked James.
His expression shifted, became more careful.
“The envelope contains a personal letter your grandfather wrote the same day we executed the POA,” James said. “He asked me to give it to you if circumstances developed the way he feared they might.”
“And the USB?”
James paused.
“In August, your grandfather and I had a lengthy consultation. He wanted certain information preserved. He asked me to record our conversation so that you would have a complete record of his state of mind, his reasoning, and the facts as he understood them.”
James’s voice was gentle.
“It’s difficult content, Anna, but he felt it was essential that you hear it in his own words.”
I picked up the envelope. My hands were trembling now. It wasn’t sealed with adhesive, just tucked closed. I opened it and pulled out a single piece of paper, lined notebook paper, the kind with three holes punched on the side. Blue ink. My grandfather’s handwriting.
The letter was short.
Anna,
If you’re reading this, it means they tried.
You’re the only one I trust.
James has everything you need.
I’m sorry you have to carry this, but I know you can.
You’re my steady girl.
Grandpa George
My eyes burned. I blinked hard, trying not to cry.
James was speaking again.
“I submitted the POA to the hospital legal department at 1:30 this afternoon,” he said. “I’ve already received confirmation that they’ve reviewed it and verified its validity.”
He pulled out his phone and showed me an email.
Timestamp: 4:00 p.m., November 22, 2025.
From: Hospital Legal Department
Subject: Health Care Proxy Verification — George Preston
The health care power of attorney dated March 18, 2025, naming Anna Marie Preston as health care agent, has been verified as valid and properly executed under Oregon law. Ms. Preston is hereby authorized to make all health care decisions for patient George Preston effective immediately. The 2018 advanced directive previously on file is superseded and no longer enforceable. All medical staff should direct health care decision inquiries to Ms. Preston as the legal health care proxy.
“As of 4:00 p.m. today,” James said, “you have full legal authority over your grandfather’s medical care. Any requests your family made to change code status? Void. Any decisions they tried to make? Overridden.”
I let out a breath I didn’t know I’d been holding.
“Thank God,” I whispered.
James started to pack up his briefcase, but he paused, looked at me seriously.
“Anna, there’s more. Significantly more. The USB drive contains information about why your grandfather felt it necessary to take these legal steps. It’s not just about health care decisions.”
He glanced at my grandfather. My grandfather gave a small nod.
For complete preparation instructions, go to the next page or click the Open button (>). Don't forget to SHARE with your friends on Facebook.
